By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
NepaliPage | Nepalese Community Affairs in AustraliaNepaliPage | Nepalese Community Affairs in Australia
  • Home
  • Who is Who
  • News
  • Events
  • Jobs
  • Students
  • Photos
  • Videos
  • Nepali NAATI CCL
Font ResizerAa
NepaliPage | Nepalese Community Affairs in AustraliaNepaliPage | Nepalese Community Affairs in Australia
Font ResizerAa
  • Home
  • Who is Who
  • News
  • Events
  • Jobs
  • Students
  • Photos
  • Videos
  • Nepali NAATI CCL
Social

Should new Australians have to pass an English test to become citizens?

Madan Mani
Last updated: January 26, 2022 9:17 pm
Madan Mani
Share
6 Min Read
SHARE

Should new Australians have to pass an English test to become citizens? - NepaliPage Matteo Bonotti, Monash University

Contents
What do other countries do?Why language tests don’t workWhat about testing basic skills?Tests as an incentive to learn EnglishWhat to do instead

On Australia Day each year, thousands of people become Australian citizens at ceremonies around the country.

Prospective citizens have to meet a number of eligibility criteria, including passing a citizenship test to show they have a reasonable knowledge of Australia and basic English.

But there are persistent suggestions those applying to be citizens should also pass a separate formal English test to prove their language skills.

In a newly published article with colleague Louisa Willoughby, we explain why this poses a range of problems and why it would not boost English proficiency among new Australians.

What do other countries do?

Language tests for citizenship have become increasingly common overseas: for example, 33 of 40 Council of Europe member states surveyed in 2018 had one.

In 2017, the Australian government also proposed adding a language test to the citizenship requirements. It backed away from the idea following a public backlash, although it continues to put a strong emphasis on the importance of English ability across the visa system.

Proponents of language tests for citizenship see them as promoting migrant integration and social inclusion. Requiring prospective citizens to pass an English test seems like an easy way to ensure they can be educated, employed and participate in society more generally.

But there are some real issues with this approach.

Read Also: New Requirements for Getting Australian Citizenship

Should new Australians have to pass an English test to become citizens? - NepaliPage

Why language tests don’t work

Language testing scholars have repeatedly criticised the tests, saying there is no evidence they help people integrate.

Furthermore, it is not clear what kind of language skills a citizenship language test should include.

As our article notes, language tests for jobs or entry to higher education have been developed by experts to reflect the linguistic demands of the relevant discipline or profession.

For example, doctors are tested on medical language and their ability to communicate respectfully and empathetically with patients, prospective university students on their academic reading and writing abilities, and so on.

But what are the language skills required to be a good citizen? We might think skills like being able to follow a political debate are a good starting point, but this is a very high bar that would exclude many people – including, potentially, some native English speakers.

What about testing basic skills?

And even if – like many European countries – we set the bar lower and asked for more basic, conversational language skills, this would still raise a number of problems. We know many factors beyond people’s control influence their ability to learn a second language after migration.

Among those who find it particularly difficult are older people, those with limited education or who are illiterate in their first language, and those who have experienced significant trauma (such as refugees and asylum seekers). Language tests risk putting citizenship out of reach for these vulnerable groups, an outcome that seems inequitable at best, discriminatory at worst.

This is complicated by the huge variation in the way people around the globe speak English, and by the need to avoid situations where those who speak English with particular accents (including, sometimes, well-educated native speakers) fail English tests because their accents are deemed too different from what the test thinks is “normal” or “standard”.

Tests as an incentive to learn English

What of the idea that tests motivate prospective citizens to learn the language of their new society?

Migrants’ motivation to learn the language of their new country cannot be assessed independently of contextual factors, especially incentives and rewards. Furthermore, migrants often face barriers around eligibility, scheduling, transport, work and childcare commitments, or lack of good quality classes.

Moreover, there is no guarantee tests actually work as an incentive. The Netherlands, for example, introduced a tough system that fines new migrants if they do not pass a Dutch test within three years of their arrival. Despite this, around one in four migrants still fails to pass the test within the required time.

Older migrants, especially those from countries where schooling is commonly interrupted (such as Afghanistan and Somalia), are particularly likely to fail the test. This reinforces the view that social and cognitive factors are more reliable predictors of language learning than lack of motivation.

Read Also: Nepalese Australian: Nepalese in Australia, where Nepalese living in Australia

Should new Australians have to pass an English test to become citizens? - NepaliPage

What to do instead

Forcing people to pass an English test in order to become Australian citizens creates a range of practical and ethical problems, while producing little benefit for migrants and their host society.

Instead, the federal government should use other measures – such as extending eligibility for its adult migrant English program – to support English learning.

Meanwhile, COVID-19 has reinforced the importance of migrant language media and migrant associations. To better support and include this part of our population, we also need to ensure people with lower English skills are able to get the information they need to fulfil the expectations and duties of citizenship.The Conversation

Matteo Bonotti, Senior lecturer, Monash University

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

TAGGED:Australian citizensAustralian CitizenshipAustralian citizenship ActAustralian Citizenship new rulesEnglish test to become citizensFeaturedNepalese Australian
Share This Article
Facebook Twitter Copy Link Print
What do you think?
Love0
Sad0
Happy0
Sleepy0
Angry0
Dead0
Wink0
By Madan Mani
Madan Mani, lives in Sydney, Software Engineer, Digital Marketeer, graduated from Federation University, has solid Journalism and Media background, worked for years in Nepalese National Dailies, Radios, Online & TVs.
Previous Article Things you should know before buying a home in Australia - NepaliPage Things you should know before buying a home in Australia
Next Article Top 7 notable Nepalese in USA - NepaliPage Top 7 notable Nepalese in USA
Leave a comment

Migration News

2025 NSW Skilled Migration Seminars - NepaliPage
Want Australian PR? Join These NSW Migration Seminars
Migration
Temporary Graduate 485 visa - NepaliPage
Australia Closes Student Visa Pathway for Temporary Graduate Visa Holders
Migration
Migration boost is bad news for Australia’s environment – we mustn’t ignore that - NepaliPage
Australia’s skilled migration policy changed how and where migrants settle
Australia Migration News
How to improve the migration system for the good of temporary migrants – and Australia - NepaliPage
Government to toughen scrutiny of international students as it slashes net migration over two years
Migration News
- Advertisement -

You Might Also Like

Importance of Saraswati Puja and how to celebrate it - NepaliPage
Social

Importance of Saraswati Puja and how to celebrate it

February 3, 2025
Sydney Arieal View
Lifestyle

Top 10 Places to Visit in Australia in 2025

January 26, 2025
Two Nepalese lost life in Sydney water - NepaliPage
AustraliaNews

Two Nepalese lost life in Sydney water

June 9, 2024
CorporateJobs

10 Top In-Demand Jobs in Australia

April 15, 2025

We acknowledge the Traditional Custodians & First Peoples of Australia (all states & territories) past, present and emerging, and honour their continued connection to the history, country, and culture.

Follow Us on Socials

Twitter Update

Tweets by NepaliPage

About Us

NepaliPage.com (नेपालीपेज डटकम) is an Australian Nepalese Community Media platform connects large number of Nepalese Australians through common interest news, views and reviews. As an Australian Community Media NepaliPage aggregates News, Australian Nepali Community Affairs from all around Australia in both Nepali and English language. Read More...

Follow Us on Facebook

Copyright © All Rights Reserved

Affiliate Disclosure | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Community Journalism Policy |
adbanner
AdBlock Detected
Our site is an advertising supported site. Please whitelist to support our site.
Okay, I'll Whitelist
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?